Showing posts with label investment banking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label investment banking. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 02, 2011

Islamic finance complexity (Part I)

I have been pulled away from blogging, mostly because I was finishing a chapter I am contributing (for a book which is coming out next year) on Islamic microfinance.  Hopefully, I'll be able to address some of the topics I was researching for the chapter in future blog posts (and newsletters).  However, first I thought it would be useful to revisit one conclusion from my last blog post on whether Islamic finance can "return to basics".  I wrote:
"The underlying reason I think that this complexity has arisen is because the Islamic finance industry has focused on creating financial products in a way that they are Shari'ah-compliant, rather than starting from 'first principles' of finance (i.e. what need are they addressing) and looking at how Islamic finance can meet these needs."
Given that the Islamic finance industry has branched into so many different areas, it is difficult to succinctly define the "financial needs" that Islamic finance is supposed to serve.  In some ways, the financial needs are not any different from the "financial needs" that conventional finance, which can lead to (somewhat deserved) cynicism about how the industry works now and whether there is anything that can usefully be accomplished within the Islamic finance industry as it is constructed now. 

But to start the thought process (this blog post and future ones on the topic are almost as much exercises for me to think through the issues as it is intended to share the thoughts with readers) every financial institution should serve two sides as an intermediary, matching the excess funds on the one side with the need for funds on the other.
  • Islamic (retail) banks: 
    • Hold Excess Funds: Depositors, Investors
    • Need Funds: Individuals, Companies
  • Islamic (investment banks) banks: 
    • Hold Excess Funds: Investors
    • Need Funds: Companies, Governments
  • Islamic investments: 
    • Hold Excess Funds: Investors
    • Need Funds: Companies
  • Takaful: 
    • Hold Excess Funds: Individuals, Companies
    • Need Funds: Individuals, Companies (when need arises in the future)
In some ways these different functions (drop any general categories I have missed in the comments) are all inter-linked.  Investment companies will invest in equity (and debt) of the Islamic banks and takaful companies.  Takaful companies will invest the premiums (donations) from policyholders in the Islamic investments.  Islamic banks will provide financing to companies that also receive investments from other Islamic financial institutions. 

These financial needs are not unique to Muslims, and the institutions should not be viewed as specifically targeted towards Muslims, nor should they necessarily be viewed as mirror images of conventional financial institutions.  My goal (if time permits) is to go through the different institutional types and look at how they are set up today both conventionally and as Islamic financial institutions and critique areas where the Islamic financial institutions have moved too far towards excess complexity at the expense of simply providing a service to meet a basic financial need. 

See the index of other posts: http://investhalal.blogspot.com/2011/11/islamic-finance-complexity.html

Friday, September 24, 2010

Friday Bullets

  • The future of Islamic finance--outside of retail banking--is moving more towards asset management with institutions realizing that the recurring revenue from this business is important to offset the highly cyclical nature of investment banking. No institution perhaps stands as a better example of overreliance on private equity/investment banking in Islamic finance than Gulf Finance House, which is planning to build its recurring revenue business now that it has extended the maturity of several loans.
  • Pakistan's central bank is urging Gulf-based Islamic banks to open branches in the rural areas of Pakistan as a way to increase the country's share of Islamic banking assets, which the bank wants to double in the next 3 years.
  • A few more articles came out on the Deloitte report on Islamic finance. One article from Gulf News includes two charts from the report that point to the need for regulation, particularly in accounting standards, risk management, corporate governance and Shari'ah standards & compliance.
  • Adnan Ahmad Yousef, CEO of Al Baraka Banking Group, says that sufficient financing is available for Islamic financial institutions and the banking group is planning a $200 million sukuk to finance the bank's expansion into France next year. Qatar Islamic Bank is also planning a sukuk issue of up to $750 million when market conditions are right, according to a statement from the bank.
  • An article describes the enforcement of an ijara-based financing in Dubai that went through the UAE court system.
  • The Islamic Bank of Britain released results for the first half of 2010.
  • The Nakheel 5-year sukuk to pay trade creditors may be issued by year-end and is estimated to be up to $3.2 billion. It will pay a 10% coupon semi-annually, will be tradable and will be listed on NASDAQ Dubai.
  • An article in Arabian Business highlights the degree to which credit conditions in sukuk markets have recovered this quarter (and also the amount they still have to go before conditions normalize): "The spread between the average yield for Islamic bonds in the UAE and the London interbank offered rate shrank 104 basis points to 507 basis points so far this quarter, according to the HSBC/NASDAQ Dubai UAE US Dollar Sukuk Index." Issuance is expected to be as much as $5 billion in the fourth quarter, the highest since Q3 ofo 2007, before the AAOIFI ruling and the impact of the financial crisis caused a sharp decline in the volume of sukuk issued.

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Thoughts before the Reuters summit on Islamic finance

The Reuters summit has not occurred yet (it is scheduled for next week) but there is one article which prefaces the summit and discusses how the industry has not yet found a way to move beyond the real estate driven crisis that began over recent years. There were four things mentioned in the article that are relevant as the industry tries to move beyond the crisis. When the summit concludes, it will be interesting to hear the different viewpoints on these areas, but in advance, I'll lay out my opinions on these four topics.

Maturity mismatches
"'This situation is very common whereby companies have gone out to get short-term funding but then put it into illiquid assets (such as real estate),' [Mohieddine Kronfol, managing director at Algebra Capital] said."

The maturity mismatch problem--that of borrowing short term to purchase long-term assets--is one that is important throughout finance. The real estate bust in the U.S. was precipitated in large part by this exact thing. Bank's structured investment vehicles (SIVs) were financed using asset-based commercial paper and then bough mortgage-backed securities. Their difficulties, which led them to be taken back onto bank's balance sheets was an inability to roll this ABCP, which created a liquidity crisis in the SIVs and the rest is history.

The Islamic banking problem is not necessarily as extreme as the SIV problems (commercial paper is debt with a maturity of less than 270 days). However, it serves as a good example of the effects of a maturity mismatch in a crisis. In Islamic banking, the maturities are generally not quite as short, but the problems remain. The financing done by Islamic banks for real estate projects, many of which were not even expected to be completed in a couple years time, was rarely in excess of 5 years. Overall, there have been few (non-Malaysian) sukuk issued with maturities of greater than 5 years and this is not necessarily surprising given that they were issued in emerging markets and the riskiness of a sukuk issue is to some degree affected by its maturity. Changing interest rates (on which the coupons on new sukuk are based), alongside with market, political and credit risks means that investors are wary of investing in longer maturity debt.

That said, the larger problem in Islamic is the over-concentration of investments in one sector (real estate) and the general collapse of several real estate markets. There is always additional risk in not diversifying and the real estate boom in the Gulf coincided with a global boom that ended in 2007-2008. The maturity mismatch is not going to be overcome quickly and the lower-than-expected size of the Dar Al Arkan sukuk suggests that issuers of sukuk who are not sovereigns or high-grade corporate issuers are not going to be received as well as they were in the boom year. The Dar Al Arkan sukuk was a 5-year sukuk, continuing the trend of shorter-maturity issues.

As the market rebounds and investors become more comfortable with sukuk, the maturity of new sukuk could lengthen. However, that will require greater institutional changes in the markets from which sukuk are issued. There needs to be greater legal certainty about whether the rules under which sukuk are issued will remain constant five years from now, let alone ten years from now if the maturity profile of new sukuk is to increase.

Reliance on transitory sources of profits
"Asset management is seen as a key growth area for the industry, but experts say it needs to diversify its products by adding fixed-income components to its funds that are focused on real estate and private equity."

The Islamic finance market has been focused a lot on the high profile deals and also those which net the financial institutions the highest fees during the past few years. There have been many structured products and private equity deals that have captured the headlines of the industry. To be fair, there has also been more development on more plain vanilla products, but it has taken a back seat to these other areas like private equity and large real estate projects.

This is great for banks when everyone's dancing (to paraphrase Chuck Prince on the eve of the crisis). However, it means that the revenue sources for many Islamic banks, particularly investment banks, is very cyclical. When these deals are plentiful, the banks are making bumper profits, but when these opportunities disappear, we see banks run into problems handling their debt load, as recent problems at Gulf Finance House (which was downgraded to 'Selective Default' in the wake of its debt restructuring/rollover) evidence.

There are more stable forms of revenue and asset management is one of them because it has a longer-term focus rather than the transactional focus on the investment banking business. It may be less lucrative in boom times, but it is often more stable in times of stress in the financial markets. This balance between different activities is not one that only applies to Islamic financial institutions, but it is one piece in the puzzle about why some Islamic financial institutions have run into trouble recently.

Lack of standardized regulation
"Regulation also remains fragmented, with central banks, its own standard-setting bodies and scholars interpreting Islamic law all having a say in governing the industry."

The issue of standardization is one of the most complex issues in Islamic finance. I have refined my own views on standardization of individual products and that is a particularly difficult area for the industry to grapple with. However, the standardization of regulation is I think less difficult. Uncertainty of how Islamic finance is in most cases negative to the industry's growth. The uncertainty, for example, on Shari'ah issues plays one factor in the lack of longer maturity sukuk because of doubts that the accepted Shari'ah standards today will be so ten years down the line. When investors look at a sukuk, the risk that the structure will not be viewed as acceptable several years down the road may detract from interest in it. This risk may be heightened by the AAOIFI revision of standards on mudaraba and musharaka, which provide tangible examples how an accepted structure could be frowned upon by Shari'ah standards in a couple years time.

There is very little the industry can do to mitigate this risk because the rules are still in flux and individual Shari'ah scholars may view different products with different levels of acceptance even at one point in time. The only thing that can reduce this uncertainty is to build an institutional framework in which standards can be established and revised. To some degree, this is already taking place with development of standards by AAOIFI and the IFSB. However, there can not be too much work towards the goal of increasing certainty about what is and is not acceptable from a Shari'ah point of view.

Lack of size among local Islamic financial institutions
"The industry also needs to create bigger players, with local banks being too small to grab market share from the Islamic windows of Western conventional banks in syndicating loans and arranging Islamic bonds, or sukuk."

To some degree, the problem with standardization of Shari'ah supervision is intertwined with the lack of local financial institutions of sufficient size to compete with Islamic windows of the global financial firms. These firms are primarily (if not solely) involved in Islamic finance with an eye to the profits from creating products that receive Shari'ah approval. They may be staffed with people who believe that Islamic finance can provide a new model for financial services based on the Shari'ah, but on an institutional level, they are focused on profits.

THe smaller (mostly GCC-based) Islamic financial institutions that compete with them also share the desire to maximize profits, but there may be more of an institutional bias towards the development of the Islamic finance industry longer-term. A fully Shari'ah-compliant financial institution will depend for its survival upon the industry remaining relevant and will have much more difficulty changing businesses if Islamic finance is stymied. The global financial institutions, on the other hand, are able to shift between the businesses (conventional and Islamic) which produce the greatest profits and may act with a short-term focus on pushing the envelope by becoming the first bank to offer a Shari'ah-compliant version of XYZ conventional product.

That being said, there are benefits for the involvement of large financial institutions with their greater resources to develop the industry and their (often) longer history of operating within global financial markets. This benefit may outweigh the short-term costs of their involvement and so long as there is sufficient infrastructure built to support the growth in the Islamic financial industry that is apart from the shorter-term focus of the global financial institutions, the industry can benefit from their involvement.

Sunday, August 02, 2009

Islamic Investment Banking 2009 report

The Yasaar Media report, Islamic Investment Banking 2009 (available free from Yasaar Media as a PDF), provides a thorough review of the history and current state of Islamic investment banking. Below, I provide a basic summary of a few areas that I found the most interesting. It is not a comprehensive summary of the report and the areas that I highlight are very limited by what I took from them. I would strongly suggest a read through this interesting, detailed and timely report.

The premise from which the report begins is that although Islamic finance has experienced a rapid burst of growth during the past decade, not all areas of Islamic finance are experiencing the same pace of growth, particularly following the credit crisis which caused a global economic crisis. In the specific area covered by the Yasaar Media report—Islamic investment banking—there has been a significant reduction in the growth rate in 2008 and thus far into 2009. The areas in which this has been most pronounced is in private equity and sukuk issuance. One reason for this shrinkage is that on the whole, Islamic financial institutions, particularly investment banks, were too concentrated, both by industry (primarily real estate) and geographically (significant focus on the GCC region). The real estate sector in the GCC provided Islamic investment banks with a high rate of return relative to other areas and also provided an asset on which the financing could be based. This gravy train of high and stable returns ended when the global economic downturn led to the bursting of what had become a large bubble in parts of the GCC.

One of the first areas tackled by the report is the significant overlap between private equity and the Islamic concept of mudaraba. While this is familiar to one who thinks on the subject, the Yasaar Media report takes the comparison one step further in light of the financial situation of the day. In conventional private equity, there is significant reliance on high levels of debt that would not be possible in an Islamic private equity transaction. In the wake of the financial crisis, ‘deleveraging’ is the word of the day and therefore the more equity-based Islamic private equity transaction could be viewed by investors as well as the recipients of the investment as a preferable means of raising private capital.

The next area where the report focuses is probably one of the smallest parts of the Islamic financial industry—venture capital. Because the Islamic venture capital industry is not developed in any size, the report provides a broad focus on what it will take for an Islamic venture capital industry to emerge and highlights the role the Malaysian government is playing to develop the industry. In the course of describing the similarities between venture capital and Islamic principles that support profit-and-loss sharing, the Yasaar Media report raises the interesting dimension of how the profit-and-loss sharing ratio should be determined to remain Shari’ah-compliant. For a sector that has been largely overlooked, this leads one to recognize how even areas that seem quite natural for Islamic finance have more complex issues of Shari’ah-compliance that have yet to be resolved.

Mergers and acquisitions, another area covered, is on with particular relevance in the current financial environment where smaller institutions may be squeezed in ways that larger rivals are not. It has been the conventional wisdom that the UAE and other parts of the GCC are ‘over-banked’ for years. However, there are difficulties caused by several factors that may limit the actual merger and acquisition activity within the Islamic financial industry. As the report states, many of the M&A activity that is possible because of depressed valuations would be desirable from an industry-wide perspective may run into regulatory hurdles or simply the problem that the banks are not ‘for sale’.

Unlike many of the areas of Islamic investment banking that have been severely hit by the financial and economic crisis of the last year, Islamic syndicated lending has been one of the first to recover and although it is on pace to fall year-on-year, its supply has recovered quite a bit more substantially than, say, the sukuk market. As mentioned above, the counterpoint to the relatively quick recovery is the rethinking that has to occur about the desirability of using real estate as a large part of an investment bank’s investment portfolio.

The section on capital markets was one that provided thorough cover of the issues facing, in particular, sukuk following questions from Sheikh Taqi Usmani about the Shari’ah-compliance of the mudaraba and musharaka sukuk which was followed by a steep drop in issuance due to the credit crisis. These problems were complicated by the default or bankruptcies of several issuers which leaves the market for new sukuk somewhat in limbo. Although a reduction of the stress facing capital markets has led Indonesia and several GCC countries to resume sovereign issues, the supply of new corporate sukuk issues remains constricted by pricing and uncertainty about default resolution.

Following on a discussion of capital markets is a detailed overview of the situation Islamic banks face in terms of liquidity management as well as the avenues that are currently being used. More than most areas of Islamic finance, the types of liquidity management tools are incredibly varied. This reflects the rather underdeveloped state of this area of Islamic finance despite its premier importance to Islamic financial institutions. This will be a continued area of stress for Islamic bankers until there is something more uniform that is able to meet the demand in a way that is both comparable in ease to conventional inter-bank lending as well as broadly accepted as Shari’ah-compliant.

The report finishes with a summary of Islamic trade finance, a quietly important area of Islamic finance that, despite the lack of attention it receives compared to sukuk and liquidity management, provides significant value to the non-financial businesses that use it. It seems a relatively good area to conclude the report since it is the area that is most important for non-financial businesses and, unlike many areas of conventional finance, this is the ultimate raison d’etre of Islamic finance.

I have written a forthcoming report for Yasaar Media on Islamic finance in North America, which will also be available on the Yasaar Media website. To receive reports as they are released, you can email media@yasaar.org with the subject line ‘Please send me your research reports immediately on publication’.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Sukuk, new investment banks, Islamic credit cards

Following the Rupiah-denominated sukuk, Indonesia's first dollar-denominated sukuk "will probably be slightly more ambitious than intended" according to an anonymous person involved in the offering.

Several GCC banks are launching three new large investment banks with focuses on infrastructure, agricultural and hospitality. The banks will use the excess liquidity created by high oil prices to direct investment in large projects with long time horizons.

Not everyone is happy about the development of Shari'ah-compliant credit cards. Some of them are significantly more expensive than their conventional alternatives without much difference in terms of how the issuer earns money from customers.

Saturday, February 09, 2008

Islamic finance in the West, new products may attract criticism within the industry

An editorial in Middle East Times by an Indonesian journalist, Wahyuana, describes the growth of Islamic finance in Indonesia, which has been rather subdued and less visible than growth elsewhere in the world like the GCC, Malaysia and the U.K. In something that is not as frequently mentioned is that the prohibition of interest-based finance is contained not just in the Qur'an (2:275, 278-279) but also the New Testament (Luke 6:34-35 - "And if ye lend to them of whom ye hope to receive, what thank have ye? for sinners also lend to sinners, to receive as much again. But love ye your enemies, and do good, and lend, hoping for nothing again; and your reward shall be great, and ye shall be the children of the Highest: for he is kind unto the unthankful and to the evil.") and the Torah (Exodus 22:25 - "If thou lend money to any of my people that is poor by thee, thou shalt not be to him as an usurer, neither shalt thou lay upon him usury.")

The Investment Dar, the Kuwaiti investment firm, is considering an investment in European or American telecom companies, which could include a 3 percent stake in SprintNextel. The Investment Dar also plans on opening an Islamic bank in the U.K. The familiarity of financial regulators with Islamic banking in the U.K. have made the country a gateway into the European market. Countries like France and Germany have minimal Islamic financial services available and Muslim populations between 5 and 10 percent of the population. European Finance House, the U.K. subsidiary of the Qatar Islamic Bank, received FSA approval to begin banking in the U.K. Initially, the bank will focus on commercial and investment banking, but has authorization to operate personal banking as well.

In the wake of comments about Shari'ah law made by the Archbishop of Canterbury, a paper in North East England describes how Islamic finance has become widely accepted and available in the country, even outside of London. The BBC has a general Q&A about Shari'ah law. There is also a thoughtful editorial in the Guardian by Asim Siddiqui.

Reuters describes the challenges facing Islamic finance in the United States, including differing state banking regulations, concentrations of Muslims in a few areas of the country and the lack of national financial institutions offering Islamic financial products, issues I have addressed in two articles I have written for Islamic Business & Finance magazine.

Sukuk growth in the GCC (largely issued in US dollars) has been led by the UAE but the majority are still coming from Malaysia, denominated in Ringgit. Credit Suisse says that the Islamic financial sector has been largely insulated from the credit crisis, despite several sukuk being delayed in the last few quarters of 2007. One of the challenges to Islamic financial growth is Islamic banks liquidity management, something I will discuss in the forthcoming issue of the Institute of Halal Investing newsletter. To be added to the mailing list, please email me at blake@investhalal.org.

The International Islamic Financial Market (IIFM) is planning to initiate greater research about sukuk, the fastest growing area of Islamic finance. The organization is also working with the International Swaps & Derivatives Association on developing a framework for Shari'ah-compliant derivatives. A key challenge is how to ensure that any derivatives are used for hedging purposes and not speculation. In addition, Islamic financial institutions are using real estate investments as an alternative to long-term bonds since long-maturity sukuk are not yet common. Deutsche Bank sees future growth in Islamic hedge funds, still seen as controversial by many people within the Islamic finance industry.

Morgan Stanley plans to be the first multi-national corporation to issue a sukuk. Given that most of the company's business is in conventional finance, there could be question about whether financing a conventional financial institution with an Islamic bond, whether or not the deal is structured to be Shari'ah compliant.

The Kuwait central bank governor Sheikh Salem Abdul Aziz Al-Sabah says Islamic banks need greater liquidity management tools. The Islamic Development Bank Solidarity Fund to fight poverty is continuing to receive contributions towards the $10 billion target. The fund has raised $1.6 billion so far.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

Malaysia, Kenya, Saudi sukuk and venture capital

EONCap Islamic Bank, the Islamic banking subsidiary of EON Bank Bhd, wants to expand into partnership-based Islamic investment banking. The acting CEO, Abdul Jamel Pawanteh commented "We hope to expand our products by taking advantage of various contracts under Islamic banking … moving towards entrepreneur-based ties rather than debtor-creditor relationships".

HSBC Holdings Plc plans to start a stand-alone Islamic bank based in Malaysia to serve Muslim customers across Asia. They hope to receive approval to offer weath management, mutual funds and retirement products in countries like Brunei, Indonesia and Bangladesh from Malaysia. HSBC Amanah, the Islamic banking arm of HSBC Holdings is based in Kuala Lumpur.

The first Islamic commercial bank in Kenya received a license to operate. The bank will be called the First Community Bank Limited. Barclays Bank Kenya and Kenya Commercial Bank both operate Islamic windows and the Gulf African Bank was due to open in April.

The first Saudi sukuk was listed on the Dubai International Financial Exchange (DIFC). There are now six sukuk listed on the exchange with a combined value of $8.98 billion. The most recently added sukuk was a $600 million issue by Dar Al Arkan Real Estate Development Company.

The managing partner of Bahrain-based venture capital firm Stratum, Marwan K. Tabbara, urged Islamic financial institutions to move into venture capital and human capital based businesses rather than just fixed assets.